1. Will China continue to export toxic toys?
Yes, China is poisoning
everyone especially its own people. 16 of the most polluted cities are in
China. 90% of urban ground water and 75% of urban surface water is polluted.
60% of drugs in developing countries are fakes, which are either ineffective or
harmful. The FDA stopped a shipment of fake Tamiflu into the US.
2. The Chinese government has
promised the US that it will closely monitor its toy exports, why won’t this
solve the problem?
The Chinese have a “command
and control problem”. As the Chinese expression goes, “the mountains are high
and the Emperor is far away.” There is no legal system. Law can function in two
ways. It can extend power or limit it. The Communist party,
who control most of the factories who produce these products have no wish to
limit their power by protecting consumers.
3. Should consumers worry
about toxic Chinese products?
Yes and no. Yes, consumers
should worry, because China will keep exporting them. No, because the legal
systems in Canada and the US work. Companies in the US are being sued and their
products boycotted. So they have both legal and economic disincentives to
insure that their products are safe. The government in the US is increasing
funding to the United States Consumer Product Safety Commission. Both the
companies and governments will test more than ever. Companies will have to
reassess their China strategies and most likely start to source more of their
products in countries with legal systems like India, which also has lower
wages.
4. Will there be a global
recession in 2008?
Yes. The present thinking is
that although there will be economic problems in the United States, the rest of
the world especially China will continue to grow. In the past few weeks while
the US stock market has dropped 7%, the Chinese stock market, the Shanghai A share market, has dropped 12%. Most commentators have
correctly pointed out that few Chinese own shares and that
foreigners cannot own Chinese A shares. What they have not understood is
that large Chinese companies are gambling with their cash flows on the Chinese
stock market. It’s as if GE, Microsoft and Boeing had used their cash flow to
invest in the Dot.com bubble. As the Chinese bubble collapses, the Chinese
companies that have been driving the commodity boom will have to retrench,
slowing the economy. The lack of demand for commodities will affect everything
from oil to copper and the countries that produce them.
5. Will jobs from the US and
Canada continue to be outsourced?
No. There are certain limits
to outsourcing, both from supply and demand. As I point out in my book, the
Indian and Chinese education systems do not produce enough educated people who
have the ability to be employed in the outsourcing industry. Both the US and
Canadian economies are based on services, many of which cannot be outsourced.
You cannot out source your barber.
6. Which country will benefit
most from globalization?
The US. In the last three years, US trade with India has
tripled. Other countries have not developed flexible institutions that can
adapt to constantly changing market conditions.
7. What institutions
specifically?
Most emerging markets have
very large state owned sectors. These range from banks to oil companies. Some
of these companies are the largest in the world. They include Saudi Arabia’s
Aramco, Venezuela’s Petroleos de Venezuela, and Russia’s Gazprom. Although
these companies have huge incomes and huge assets, they often do not make any
money. The reason is simple. State owned companies are run for political
reasons, not profit. So a company like Gazprom does not make any money because
it sells gas at low prices in Russia and has enormous costs due to corruption.
8. Will China surpass the US
economically?
No. There are many reasons,
but one of the most important is about information. Free markets are about
choice. To make an informed choice you need accurate and timely information. To
get accurate information you need free speech. If speech is not protected, or
as in China active suppressed, so no one knows anything including China
leaders. It is impossible to make the right decisions about investments or
government policy because the information in inaccurate.
9. Will China surpass the US
in innovation?
No. You can get a thousand
brilliant Chinese scientists in a building. They will undoubtedly come up with
some great innovations. The problem is that China does not have intellectual
property laws, so these innovations will be stolen the next day. Bank loans go
to state owned industries, so private entrepreneurs have no access to money.
10. How will future changes
in the global economy affect global warming?
I believe it could impact the world in a positive manner. A slowdown in China will most likely decrease its need for energy, which, since most of it comes from coal, will no doubt help the environment. It may also cause political instability. China last year experienced over 80,000 large scale riots. The combination of pollution, slow growth and large wealth disparities may be toxic to the communist party. In contrast, the US has huge economic, environmental and political incentives to go green. Since the incentives exist in almost every economic sector, it may be the impetus for economic growth in the same way that the internet revolutionized almost everything we do. If it does happen, it could remove much of what is strategically important about the Middle East and Russia. As a former Saudi oil minister once said, “The stone age did not end for lack of stones.”